If you own commercial property in California and lease it to an LLC or a corporation, the personal guaranty is often the only thing standing between a default and an uncollectible judgment. A tenant entity can be emptied of assets in a weekend; an individual guarantor with a home, investment accounts, and other businesses cannot. Borna Houman Law represents commercial landlords from its Santa Monica office in drafting, negotiating, and enforcing lease guaranties across Los Angeles County, and this guide explains what California law requires for a guaranty to hold.
Key Takeaway: A personal guaranty of a commercial lease in California must be in writing and signed by the guarantor. It is enforceable for the full tenant obligation unless capped by its terms, but a landlord who changes the lease without the guarantor’s consent can release the guarantor under Civil Code section 2819 unless the guaranty contains an effective section 2856 waiver.
Most contested guaranty cases turn on that exoneration question. In our experience representing Westside commercial owners, the guaranty language itself is rarely the problem. The problem is the amendment, the rent deferral, or the assignment consent the landlord signed years later without bringing the guarantor back to the table.
Drafting a new lease or chasing a defaulted tenant’s guarantor? Borna Houman Law represents commercial property owners in lease drafting, guaranty enforcement, and commercial unlawful detainer actions. Call (888) 42-BORNA to schedule a confidential consultation.
What is a personal guaranty in a commercial lease?
A personal guaranty is a separate contract in which an individual, usually the tenant’s owner, promises the landlord to pay or perform the tenant’s lease obligations if the tenant does not. The tenant entity remains the primary obligor. The guarantor stands behind it with personal assets.
California law treats a guarantor as a surety. Civil Code section 2787 abolished the old distinction between sureties and guarantors, so the suretyship statutes in sections 2787 through 2855 govern every lease guaranty. Those statutes give guarantors a set of defenses by default. A landlord’s guaranty form exists largely to waive them.
A guaranty can cover rent only, or every tenant obligation under the lease, including operating expenses, taxes, insurance, repair and restoration costs, indemnity, and attorney fees. If you own a triple net building, the guaranty should expressly reach the NNN charges; our guide to California commercial lease agreements covers how those charges are defined in the lease itself, and our commercial lease attorneys draft the guaranty to match.
Does a lease guaranty have to be in writing in California?
Yes. A promise to answer for the debt or default of another is within the statute of frauds and is unenforceable unless it is in writing and signed by the party to be charged, under Civil Code section 1624(a)(2). An owner’s oral assurance that “I’ll make sure the rent gets paid” is not a guaranty.
Have the guarantor sign in an individual capacity, with no title after the name. A signature reading “Jane Smith, Managing Member” invites the argument that the signer bound only the company. Collect the guarantor’s driver’s license, home address, and, where the deal size justifies it, a personal financial statement signed under a representation that it is true.
What makes a guarantor’s obligation enforceable for the full amount?
A guarantor is liable for the full tenant obligation unless the guaranty limits it, but never for more than the tenant owes. Under Civil Code section 2809, a surety’s obligation may not be larger in amount or more burdensome than the principal’s, and if it is, it is reduced to the principal’s level.
That ceiling is usually generous. When a commercial tenant abandons, the landlord’s damages under Civil Code section 1951.2 can include unpaid rent earned to the date of the award, the present value of rent for the balance of the term minus the rental loss the tenant proves could have been reasonably avoided, and other detriment caused by the breach. A guarantor who signed an unlimited guaranty answers for all of it.
By default, a guarantor may also require the landlord to proceed against the tenant first, under Civil Code section 2845. A properly drafted waiver removes that requirement and lets the landlord sue the guarantor directly, in the same action as the tenant or in a separate one.
Which guaranty structure should a landlord accept?
The right structure depends on the tenant’s credit, the landlord’s tenant-improvement investment, and how hard it would be to re-lease the space. Strong tenants negotiate limits. A landlord’s job is to make sure each limit is priced against the risk it creates.
| Guaranty type | What the guarantor covers | Landlord risk | When it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full (unlimited) guaranty | Every tenant obligation for the entire term | Lowest | New business, heavy TI allowance, specialized buildout |
| Capped guaranty | Obligations up to a fixed dollar amount, for example 12 months of rent | Moderate; exposure above the cap is unsecured | Established tenant with partial credit history |
| Burn-off guaranty | Full or capped liability that reduces or ends after a set period of on-time payment | Rises over time | Tenant with a short operating history but strong early performance |
| Good-guy guaranty | Rent and charges only through the date the tenant gives notice and surrenders the space in the required condition | Highest; landlord bears re-leasing and vacancy | Office tenants in markets with strong re-leasing demand |
Consider a Santa Monica retail space leased to an LLC at $18,000 a month for ten years, with a $240,000 tenant improvement allowance. If the tenant fails in year three, a good-guy guaranty with a 90-day notice period exposes the guarantor to roughly three months of rent, about $54,000, plus charges. The landlord still carries the unamortized part of the $240,000 allowance, about $168,000 on straight-line amortization after three years, plus the vacancy. A guaranty capped at the unamortized allowance plus 12 months of rent ($216,000) starts at $456,000 and steps down as the allowance amortizes, which matches the guarantor’s exposure to the landlord’s actual investment. In our experience, that is the cap sophisticated tenants accept most readily, because it is easy to justify line by line.
Can a lease amendment release the guarantor?
Yes. Under Civil Code section 2819, a surety is exonerated if the creditor, without the surety’s consent, alters the principal’s original obligation in any respect or impairs or suspends the creditor’s remedies against the principal. In a lease, the creditor is the landlord and the principal is the tenant.
Ordinary lease events can trigger that rule if the guaranty does not address them:
- A rent deferral or abatement agreement with the tenant.
- An amendment expanding the premises or extending the term on new economics.
- A consent to assignment that changes the tenant’s obligations, or a consent to a sublease that releases the original tenant.
- An agreement to accept partial rent and forgo a default.
The fix is two-layered. First, the guaranty should state that the guarantor consents in advance to amendments, extensions, renewals, assignments, and modifications, and that liability continues as to the lease as modified. Second, the landlord should still have the guarantor sign a short reaffirmation with every amendment. The advance consent answers the exoneration argument, and the signed reaffirmation keeps the guarantor from raising it at all. Our guide to commercial sublease and assignment enforcement covers the consent letters where this most often goes wrong.
What does a Civil Code 2856 waiver do?
A section 2856 waiver lets the guarantor give up the suretyship defenses that California otherwise provides, and California courts enforce it in commercial guaranties. Civil Code section 2856 allows a guarantor to waive subrogation, reimbursement, and contribution rights, the defenses in sections 2787 through 2855 (including exoneration under section 2819 and the proceed-first right under section 2845), and defenses arising from the creditor’s election of remedies.
Section 2856(b) provides that a contract term showing intent to waive is effective without any particular wording or reference to specific statutes. Many landlord forms still list the sections by number, which costs nothing. The risk is a waiver drafted so narrowly that a guarantor can argue it never reached the specific change the landlord made.
Be careful with a security deposit or letter of credit. If the lease lets the landlord apply the deposit, the guaranty should say the guarantor’s liability is not reduced until the landlord actually applies it, and that the landlord has no duty to apply it before pursuing the guarantor.
Can the guarantor’s spouse or community property be reached?
Generally yes, as to community property. Under Family Code section 910, the community estate is liable for a debt incurred by either spouse during the marriage, regardless of which spouse signed. A guaranty signed by one married guarantor can therefore reach community assets.
The non-signing spouse’s separate property is a different matter; it is generally not liable for the other spouse’s contract debts. If the deal size makes separate property relevant, ask both spouses to sign, or take a guaranty from the spouse who holds the assets. A spousal consent signed at lease execution is far easier to obtain than a judgment debtor examination after default.
Should a landlord take a letter of credit instead of a guaranty?
A letter of credit or a large cash deposit gives the landlord money it can draw immediately, while a guaranty gives the landlord a lawsuit against a person. The two do different jobs, and many Westside leases use both. An irrevocable standby letter of credit from a bank lets the landlord draw on default without suing anyone, which is valuable when the guarantor’s assets are hard to reach or held in trusts.
The tradeoff is size. Tenants rarely post a letter of credit larger than six to twelve months of rent, so it covers the first stage of a default, not the full remaining term. A guaranty reaches the rest. When a strong tenant refuses a personal guaranty, a common compromise is a larger letter of credit that burns down on a schedule tied to on-time payment, with the full guaranty springing back if the tenant defaults during the burn-down period.
How does a landlord enforce a guaranty after a default?
The landlord enforces a guaranty by demand and, if necessary, a civil action for breach of the guaranty, which can be filed alongside or after the commercial unlawful detainer against the tenant. The unlawful detainer recovers possession quickly; the guaranty action recovers money. Our guide to commercial eviction in California covers the possession track.
Before filing, confirm the tenant entity’s status on the California Secretary of State business entities page. A suspended or dissolved tenant is one more reason to look to the guarantor. Then send a written demand that cites the guaranty, attaches the default notice to the tenant, and states the amount due. Many guarantors pay at this stage once they see their name on the demand.
If the guarantor does not pay, the claim proceeds in Los Angeles County Superior Court as an ordinary civil case. The California courts’ civil lawsuit guide outlines the process. Most commercial guaranties include an attorney fee clause; if yours does, the prevailing party recovers fees, and that cuts both ways if the guarantor wins on an exoneration defense.
If the tenant files bankruptcy, the automatic stay generally protects the tenant, not the individual guarantor. The guaranty should state that the guarantor’s liability is not reduced, released, or limited by the tenant’s bankruptcy or by any cap on the landlord’s claim against the bankruptcy estate. That clause has to be in the guaranty at signing; a guarantor will not agree to add it after the tenant files.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you need a guarantor for a commercial lease in California?
No law requires one, but most California landlords require a personal guaranty from the owner of a tenant entity that lacks an operating history or audited financials. The guaranty is a negotiated term. Strong-credit tenants often trade it for a larger security deposit or a letter of credit.
Can a guarantor revoke a lease guaranty?
A guaranty of a specific lease covers the obligations the tenant took on in that lease, and the guarantor cannot unilaterally walk away from them mid-term. A guaranty drafted as a continuing guaranty of future transactions raises separate revocation questions, which is why landlord forms tie the guaranty to the identified lease and its amendments.
Does a guaranty survive if the landlord sells the building?
It should, if it is drafted to benefit the landlord’s successors and assigns. Buyers and lenders review guaranties during due diligence, and a missing successors clause is a common estoppel issue; see our guide to estoppel certificates for commercial leases. Assign the guaranty expressly in the sale documents.
What is a good-guy guaranty?
A good-guy guaranty limits the guarantor’s liability to rent and charges through the date the tenant gives the agreed notice and vacates the space in the required condition. It shifts vacancy and re-leasing risk to the landlord. It works best where the landlord’s tenant improvement investment is small and demand for the space is strong.
Is a guarantor liable for attorney fees?
Only if the guaranty or the lease it covers provides for fees and the guaranty extends to that obligation. Most landlord forms do both. Under California’s reciprocity rule for contract fee clauses, a guarantor who wins can also recover fees, so a weak claim carries real cost.
Can a landlord sue the guarantor without suing the tenant?
Yes, if the guaranty waives the guarantor’s right under Civil Code section 2845 to require the landlord to proceed against the tenant first. Without that waiver, the guarantor can insist that the landlord pursue the tenant. Most commercial forms include the waiver.
Protect the Lease Before You Need the Guaranty
Borna Houman Law represents commercial landlords and property owners only, drafting guaranties that survive amendments, assignments, and bankruptcy, and enforcing them when a tenant fails. We serve owners across Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Century City, West Los Angeles, and all of Los Angeles County through our commercial lease practice and commercial lease dispute practice. Call (888) 42-BORNA to schedule a confidential consultation.
By Borna Houman, Attorney at Law (California State Bar #352339), Borna Houman Law, 2530 Wilshire Blvd, Santa Monica, CA.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about California law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Guaranty enforceability depends on the specific contract language and facts; consult an attorney about your lease.